
In this screenshot from Gavel Alaska, Alaska Supreme Court Justice Jude Pate listens to oral arguments on Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, in a lawsuit between the Alaska Legislature and Gov. Mike Dunleavy. (Screenshot)
The Alaska Supreme Court heard oral arguments Thursday on a year-old dispute between Gov. Mike Dunleavy and the Alaska Legislature over a basic question: If the governor issues an executive order during a special session and the Legislature disapproves, do lawmakers need to vote it down during the special session, or can they wait until the next regular session?
“We agree with the governor that this issue is not squarely addressed by precedent,” legislative attorney Kevin Cuddy told the court Thursday, “and the reason for that, we submit, is because no governor in the history of the state has ever attempted to … shoehorn 40 changes of Alaska statutory law into a special session that is constitutionally limited to just 30 days.”
During a special session in August 2025, Dunleavy issued an executive order that would have created a cabinet-level Alaska Department of Agriculture. Alaska and Rhode Island are the only states without one, and a special task force on food security had recommended its creation in 2022.
Lawmakers had voted down a previous executive order on the issue and disagreed with the governor’s repeat attempt, saying they preferred to create the agency via legislation. Despite that preference, the Legislature failed to pass an enabling bill in 2025, prompting Dunleavy to reissue the executive order in August.
Alaska Legislature halts Dunleavy effort to create agriculture department
The Alaska Constitution permits legislators to halt executive orders with a joint vote of the state House and Senate, but if an executive order is issued during a special session, the Constitution is vague about whether that vote must take place during the special session or if it can wait until the Legislature’s next regular session.
Article III, Section 23 of the Alaska Constitution says in part, “The legislature shall have sixty days of a regular session, or a full session if of shorter duration, to disapprove these executive orders.”
In August 2025, legislators declined to vote on the agriculture order, and the governor said the failure to vote meant the department could go forward.
Legislators disagreed with that interpretation of the constitution and sued Dunleavy to block the move. At the end of 2025, Juneau Superior Court Judge Mariana Carpeneti ruled that the Legislature was correct, blocking the department’s creation.
The Dunleavy administration appealed to the Alaska Supreme Court, which received written arguments through the year before taking oral argument Thursday in Anchorage.
Alaska Department of Law attorney Laura Fox, representing the governor, said justices should stick to the plain language of the constitution when interpreting the dispute.
“A special session is a session,” she said. “The court does not add missing words to the constitution, and you’d need to add missing words in order to limit the governor’s executive reorganization power … to only regular sessions of the Legislature.”
Cuddy, an attorney hired on contract to represent the Legislature, said justices should look at the history of the state’s constitutional convention. Three preliminary drafts of Article 23 all said “that executive orders requiring the force of law shall become effective at the close of the next regular session of the legislature, unless there is a legislative veto,” Cuddy explained.
That changed in the final version of the constitution because its authors envisioned having no end date for the regular session, he said.
“There is simply no mention of special sessions anywhere. It’s not in the drafts. It’s not in the committee reports. Not even mentioned once in all of the debates. That silence matters,” Cuddy said.
Four of the court’s five members were appointed by Dunleavy. The lone member who was not, Chief Justice Susan Carney, was traveling and absent from Thursday’s oral argument. Staff for the Supreme Court said she could participate in the case if needed to break a tie.
Justice Dario Borghesan, presiding over Thursday’s arguments, said the court will issue a written decision at a future date.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Courtesy of Alaska Beacon