SIGNS OF SPRING - A pair of seiners from out of town are pictured tied up to the Crescent Harbor visitor dock this morning as snow falls. Herring seiners in town for the Sitka Sound sac roe herring fishery and March snow flurries are traditional signs of spring in Sitka. (Sentinel Photo by James Poulson)

Speedy Repairs Put Cable Back On Line
17 Mar 2025 14:50

SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer GCI wrapped up emergency maintenance on the undersea fiberopt [ ... ]

Planners Pass STR, Put Tower on Hold
17 Mar 2025 14:48

By CATHY LI For the Sentinel A conditional use permit for a short-term rental [ ... ]

Tlingit Code Talker Louis Minard Due Honor
17 Mar 2025 14:47

By Sentinel Staff The family of Louis Minard invites the community to commemorate his ser [ ... ]

House Bill Aims to Cut Alaska Gun Death Rate
17 Mar 2025 14:37

By CORINNE SMITH Alaska Beacon Alaska has the fifth-highest rate of gun deaths in the nation, with  [ ... ]

F&G’s Killing of Bears Ruled Unconstitutional
17 Mar 2025 14:36

By JAMES BROOKS  Alaska Beacon The Alaska Department of Fish and Game’s decision to kill almost [ ... ]

Court: Principal’s Insult Not a Free Speech Case
17 Mar 2025 14:35

By JAMES BROOKS  Alaska Beacon Neither an Alaska free-speech law nor the First Amendment protect  [ ... ]

March 17, 2025, Police Blotter
17 Mar 2025 14:33

Police received the following calls as of 8 a.m. today. March 14 A mother said her underage son wa [ ... ]

Community Happenings, Monday, March 17, 2025
17 Mar 2025 14:31

Spring Art Walk Slated April 5 All are invited to join downtown merchants and galleries in celebra [ ... ]

City Clerk Sets Election On Petition
14 Mar 2025 16:08

SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer Sitka city clerk Sara Peterson said today she has certified t [ ... ]

Original Artist Grind To Feature Fresh Air
14 Mar 2025 16:05

SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer One of the acts at Saturday’s Original Artist Grind will ce [ ... ]

City League VB Games
14 Mar 2025 16:03

GARLAND KENNEDY
Sentinel Staff Writer In the final night of City League volleyball gameplay before a [ ... ]

Judge Backs NMFS In Trawl Fishing Decision
14 Mar 2025 16:01

By JAMES BROOKS Alaska Beacon Federal fisheries managers did not mishandle trawl fishing  [ ... ]

B.C. Plans Vehicle Toll To Counter U.S. Tariffs
14 Mar 2025 16:00

By JAMES BROOKS Alaska Beacon The government of British Columbia filed legislation Thursday that wo [ ... ]

State Regulators Reject Permit for Gold Project
14 Mar 2025 15:56

By YERETH ROSEN  Alaska Beacon Alaska regulators have rejected a permit application for a controv [ ... ]

March 14, 2025, Police Blotter
14 Mar 2025 15:50

The following calls were received by police as of 8 a.m. today. March 13 Police advised a housing  [ ... ]

March 14, 2025, Community Happenings
14 Mar 2025 15:47

Climate Connection: Real Estate Bubble The White House has instructed federal agencies to remove al [ ... ]

Higher Income Saves Cuts to Parks & Rec
13 Mar 2025 15:40

SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer Increases in anticipated property tax revenues, reduced legal [ ... ]

Court-Issued Stay Puts Sitkans Back at Work
13 Mar 2025 15:39

GARLAND KENNEDY
Sentinel Staff Writer A month after the mass firing of probationary workers with the [ ... ]

Volleyball City League Update
13 Mar 2025 15:35

By Sentinel Staff In another competitive division City League volleyball match Wednesday, Ludvig's  [ ... ]

State House Approves Hard-Fought School Funding Bi...
13 Mar 2025 15:35

By CORRINE SMITH Alaska Beacon The Alaska House of Representatives passed a bill on Wednesday that  [ ... ]

New Revenue Forecast Shows Big State Deficit
13 Mar 2025 15:31

By JAMES BROOKS Alaska Beacon The state of Alaska is still facing a significant budget deficit desp [ ... ]

March 13, 2025, Police Blotter
13 Mar 2025 15:23

The following calls were received by police as of 8 a.m. today. March 12 A caller asked for a welf [ ... ]

March 13, 2025, Community Happenings
13 Mar 2025 15:23

Maritime Heritage Plans Pub Talk The Sitka Maritime Heritage Society, in collaboration with the Al [ ... ]

Water Purchase Offer Rejected by Assembly
12 Mar 2025 15:42

SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer It took the Assembly about an hour to wrap up business at Tue [ ... ]

Other Articles

Daily Sitka Sentinel

Public Weighs In On Baranof Statue

By SHANNON HAUGLAND
Sentinel Staff Writer

The Assembly heard comments Tuesday night from Sitkans calling for the removal of the Alexander Baranof statue from in front of Harrigan Centennial Hall.

A number of residents came forward in the two Persons to Heard segments of the regular Assembly meeting to say why they believed the bronze statue of the 19th century Russian merchant known as the governor of Russian America should be taken away from its prominent location.

Doug Osborne led off the public comments, reporting that more than 900 signatures had been collected in favor of the statue’s removal, and that it should be done in the interest of “healing and reconciliation.”

He said today that the signature drive was started by Kari Johnson Saturday night. Since then more than 1,080 people have signed, Osborne said, and estimated 800 are from Sitka.

Several other speakers followed, including Harriet Beleal, president of ANB Camp 1; Nancy Furlow, president of ANS Camp 4; Paulette Moreno, Chandler O’Connell, Tom Gamble, Scott Maxwell, Bob Sam and Nick Galanin. Gamble and George Paul also testified at the end of the meeting on the issue.

Most of those who spoke were in favor of removing the statue, with additional suggestions of erecting a monument to Native Alaskans.

“Most of you probably know the history in Sitka, about the 1804 battle in Sitka,” Beleal said. “I would like to remind everyone here our people were not treated very good then and died defending their land here... I would like to say that racial prejudice just doesn’t stop, as we all know. Sometimes it goes down from generation to generation.”

Moreno said, “With a heart of unity today we come together today and provide an opportunity for the City of Sitka and the Assembly to speak their mind that all people, all cultures, all races are invited, are welcome and can exist in their own unique way, within our community. One of those ways is to have a place on an island that reflects the first people of this land, that reflects the true history of the people. To have statues, benches, signs, memorials not only to those who have been here in the last two to three hundred years but to those who have been here for time immemorial ...”

“It symbolizes some horrific things, but it’s part of our history,” Tom Gamble said. “We said this is the guy we beat in 1802 and 1804 and 1805 ... until finally he decided to give us a peace hat.” He suggested a bronze statue of Elizabeth Peratrovich at the roundabout.

“Removing the statue harms no one and creates the opportunity for a healthier and more balanced community, where we can hope we have more historical understanding, more accurate context on what shapes our community today,” Chandler O’Connell said. 

The Alexander Baranof statue, pictured with a patina of bird droppings in front of Harrigan Centennial Hall, was at the center of a protest Tuesday evening just prior to the Assembly meeting. A group of Sitkans is calling for the removal of the 31-year-old statue that depicts the Russian American Company chief manager of the early 1800s. About 50 protesters and a half-dozen statue supporters turned out for the event. (Sentinel Photo by James Poulson) 

Before the Assembly meeting about a hundred people held a rally at the statue calling for its removal, with Dionne Brady-Howard and other speakers, and a Tlingit song.

The statue was a gift to the city from Lloyd and Barbara Hames in 1989, commemorating the family’s 40 years in business here. 

In their first public comments on the controversy, Lloyd and Barbara Hames’ grandsons Andrew, Brian and Roger spoke about the good intentions of their grandparents.

“No ill intent was ever meant by our family with this action,” Andrew said, reading a prepared statement. “The conversation in the community surrounding this statue has ebbed and flowed over the years and has surfaced again in light of recent national events. The statue was intended to celebrate our community’s rich history, and the humble role our family has been fortunate to play in it.”

Brian said the family is grieved that the statue offends any community member.

“We value and appreciate the rich diversity of Sitka’s people. We feel that whether the statue stays in its current location or is to be moved elsewhere is not our decision to make. This statue was a gift, and like any gift, whatever is ultimately done with it is up to the recipient, the City of Sitka.”

Roger made the closing comments.

“Dignity and respect, and honoring diversity and culture are some of our core operating values as a company,” he said.

Public comments came to an abrupt stop following the testimony of Nick Galanin, who spoke by teleconference. He suggested replacing the Baranof statue with one that recognizes the contributions of Native Alaskans, such as Elizabeth Peratrovich, William Paul or Katlian. He said the Baranof statue “celebrates the history of white supremacy and ignores the history of murder, rape, torture and enslavement of indigenous people (Baranof) committed. ... Is Sitka a community that will choose to profit from cultural tourism while erasing the history of my culture?”

Galanin also took exception to an email written by Assembly member Valorie Nelson to Larry Edwards, who asked the Assembly to have an open discussion about removing the statue. In her email to Edwards, Nelson said, “Maybe we should remove the totem poles and the war canoe ... ,’’ listed other controversies and ended with a suggestion that if he didn’t like Sitka there are other places to live.

“I’d like to ask that Valorie Nelson steps down from her position,” Galanin said. “I don’t think she’s capable of serving the community with words like that.”

Nelson left her seat at the Assembly table to speak from the public side. She said there was more to the email that wasn’t read. She shared that she had been sexually assaulted as a young child but holds no animosity toward any group of people. She said she is tired of the divisiveness.

“This is wrong, what’s going on. It’s divisive. .... I’m not going to take this any more. Thank you. If I need to step down I will.”

“You will not step down,” Mayor Gary Paxton responded. “You’re a valued member of our Assembly.”

He called an end to public testimony. Coverage of the rest of the regular Assembly meeting will appear in Thursday’s Sentinel.

Paxton added, “As we go forward on this we need to do it in a Christian, civil manner without intimidation, telling our story, and letting our community come together in a positive way to solve what we heard today.”

 

 

 

 

 

You have no rights to post comments

Login Form

 

20 YEARS AGO

March 2005

Photo caption: Sitka High School’s Zach Carlson and Barrow’s Jake Voss get a grip on a loose ball, while Sitka’s Jayson Asnin tries to get in on the play. The Wolves beat Barrow 81-77 in triple overtime, Saturday at SHS. 

50 YEARS AGO

March 1975

A catered dinner will be held after “Trial by Jury,” the concert presented by the Sitka Concert Association as a benefit for the Boy Scouts of America. Tickets are $5 each and reservations must be made by Monday.

Calendar

Local Events

Instagram

Daily Sitka Sentinel on Instagram!

Facebook

Daily Sitka Sentinel on Facebook!