Log in Subscribe

City Ordinance 2026-20

Posted

Dear Editor: The proposals put forth by administrator John Leach in "Proposed Ordinance No. 2026-20 – Commercial Passenger Vehicles: Repeal and Replace Chapter 6,30 of the Sitka General Code; Adoption of Implementing Regulations" fail to meet any standard of public interest in innumerable ways.

They effectively triple existing cab fares. Most people who rely on taxis do so to get to work. They are the "working poor," most of whom work in bars and taverns for $15 hr. Many are accustomed to paying $6 for taking taxis to work. Under Leach's plan, they will be charged either $18 or $30, one way. Double that for the daily round trip. The $30 fares begin at Seamart. The $18 starts at the roundabout.

The existing city fare schedule is staggered, costing more the farther you travel out the road. Leach's plan calls for essentially two fares, out Sawmill Creek Road or Halibut Point Road: $18 (one way) anywhere past the roundabout. So downtown to Lakeside Grocery, Paxton Manor, Market Center, even Tongass Credit Union, will be an $18 fare. Past Seamart and the corresponding distance on Sawmill Creek Road the fare leaps to $30. No staggering, nothing in between: $18 or $30. People making $15 hr. simply cannot afford $36 or $60 per day for transportation. That's half of their wage per day.

Most odious: Leach proposed two or three pages of fines and penalties for taxi drivers who deviate from his fare schedule – including a $250 fine for those charging less than the fares he envisions. Which is simply outrageous. If I wish to discount fares for elders, handicapped, or anybody I want , who has any right to interfere with that?

The fare schedule in effect now is based on mileage and the price of fuel. Leach would require a 50% discount for fares originating on outer HPR or SMC. It costs a taxi the same, to the ferry from Sandy Beach as it does from downtown. But, according to the whim and caprice of John Leach, the run from Sandy Beach will cost half of what it does from downtown. Meaning that taxi drivers will simply tell customers "I'm sorry, we don't have a cab available."

The worst part of Leach's proposal is the demand that taxis choose between taxi, shuttle or tours. Some nonsense that was tried to force on us in 2023. Taxis were forced to remove the words "shuttle" and "tours" from their vehicles. Shuttles and tours were deemed to be "un-regulated," as such not subject to the taxi fare schedule. Most of them added the word "taxi" all over their vehicles. Some simply say "rides." It was all just a lot of semantic nonsense, used to evade the fare rate schedule and the necessity of paying the $7,000 per cab in insurance.

Taxi drivers have a right to talk about anything they want with customers, under the 1st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, history or anything they want. We are further guaranteed the right to engage in an economic enterprise pursuant to the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, and, Article 1, section 1, of the Alaska Constitution. Car rentals charge $300 a day now, in times of peak demand. Hotels charge $300 night. Why are taxis singled out for all this scrutiny? Especially the $250 fine for undercharging the fare rates envisioned under administrator Leach.

My driver, John Gonzalez, has now collected exactly 169 signatures of taxi clientele opposed to the proposed regulations. If the city wants to clean up the taxi business, just contact those 169 people and ask who the gougers and cheaters are in the taxi business. It's no secret who is overcharging/stealing from the customers. Many of those gouging the tourists simply disappear in the winter, because the local taxi clientele knows what the taxi fares are. They cannot be cheated like the tourists can.

The transportation proposals are a completely unworkable, unsalvageable mess. Please scrap them and begin with a process that includes the stakeholders, and the concerns of the 169 taxi users who signed up opposing this nonsense. Under the existing fare schedule, taxi fare to the ferry dock is $19 seven miles out, seven miles back. Fourteen miles on the taxi, for a $19 fare comes to $1.35 per mile.

The Assembly could tweak the existing scheduled by simply increasing $1.35 per mile to $1.50 per mile, or even $2 per mile. Just about anything would be better than the present proposed rules Assembly members Scott Saline and Thor Christianson want to require a smart phone app "to see that fares are based on mileage," which they already are. And at least one cab driver has already lost his chauffeur's Pdi license for operating his smart phone while driving, a violation of state law that 169 people are on record in opposition to the proposed revisions to taxi regulations. It would be pretty arrogant of the Assembly to ignore that.

Sigurd D. Rutter

Sitka taxi operator for 17 years