ALASKAN FLAVOR – Young dancers Eloise Branch, Ella Haley Colliver, Maddox Dozier, Molly Hames, Maddy McDevitt, Aurora Phillips and Annie White emerge from the skirt of Mother Ginger, played by Jill Kisaka, during a rehearsal for “The Nutcracker” Wednesday. The Alaska-themed ballet opens 7 p.m. tonight at the Performing Arts Center. Tickets are on sale at and at the door. (Sentinel Photo by James Poulson)

Inflation, Zoning, STRs Cited for Housing Crisis
01 Dec 2023 15:26

By GARLAND KENNEDY Sentinel Staff Writer High construction costs, restrictive zoning, and short-te [ ... ]

Tourism Task Force Seeks More Input
01 Dec 2023 15:24

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer The Tourism Task Force hopes its second open house set f [ ... ]

Volunteers Working On Bus Permit Plan
01 Dec 2023 15:22

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Assembly member Thor Christianson says he is working on  [ ... ]

Missionary, Scholar Archpriest Oleksa Dies
01 Dec 2023 15:20

By Sitka Sentinel Staff The well-known Russian Orthodox missionary and scholar, Archpriest Michael  [ ... ]

Inuit Seek Bigger Role in National Climate Action
01 Dec 2023 15:15

By YERETH ROSEN Alaska Beacon The Inuit people of the Arctic, facing some of the most dramatic eff [ ... ]

December 1, 2023, Police Blotter
01 Dec 2023 14:11

Police Blotter Sitka police received the following calls by 8 a.m. today: November 30 At 5:37 a.m [ ... ]

December 1, 2023, Community Happenings
01 Dec 2023 14:06

Climate Change: Indoor Air Quality Most climate air quality concerns are for wildfire smoke and out [ ... ]

Schools Get Warning About Gender Issues
30 Nov 2023 15:21

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Sitka School Superintendent Steve Bradshaw has received  [ ... ]

Flow Better, but Spring Loses Artesian Status
30 Nov 2023 15:19

By GARLAND KENNEDY Sentinel Staff Writer Following six weeks of repair and restoration work, water [ ... ]

November 30, 2023, Community Happenings
30 Nov 2023 12:24

Frederick Mork Dies at Age 68 Frederick Martin Mork died November 27 at his home in Sitka. He was  [ ... ]

November 30, 2023, Police Blotter
30 Nov 2023 12:12

Police Blotter Sitka police received the following calls by 8 a.m. today: November 29 At 2 a.m. a [ ... ]

Assembly Postpones Vote on Airport Lease
29 Nov 2023 15:04

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Assembly members expressed support for renewal of the ci [ ... ]

Nutcracker Back with Special Sitka Touches
29 Nov 2023 14:30

By GARLAND KENNEDY Sentinel Staff Writer Featuring iconic holiday music and ballet routines, a mul [ ... ]

Deadly Wrangell Landslide Part of a Pattern
29 Nov 2023 14:27

By YERETH ROSEN Alaska Beacon As the Southeast Alaska community of Wrangell mourns and continues t [ ... ]

November 29, 2023, Police Blotter
29 Nov 2023 14:20

Police Blotter Sitka police received the following calls by 8 a.m. today: November 28 At 12:30 a. [ ... ]

November 29, 2023, Community Happenings
29 Nov 2023 14:12

‘Light-Up Lincoln’trong>Event, Party Dec. 2 The third annual Light-Up Lincoln Street will be held a [ ... ]

Airport Lease Dilemma on Assembly Table
28 Nov 2023 15:21

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Does the city want to enter into a new lease agreement w [ ... ]

Sea Walk Phase II Needs More Funds
28 Nov 2023 15:18

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Inflationary pressure is raising costs of Phase II of th [ ... ]

Conservationists Back New SE Native Corps.
28 Nov 2023 15:17

By JOAQLIN ESTUS Alaska Beacon The conservation group the Wilderness Society has changed its posit [ ... ]

November 28, 2023, Police Blotter
28 Nov 2023 13:14

Police Blotter Sitka police received the following calls by 8 a.m. today: November  27 At 1:38 a [ ... ]

November 28, 2023, Community Happenings
28 Nov 2023 13:11

Moose to Host Holiday Party Sitka Moose Lodge and Women of the Moose will hold the children’s ho [ ... ]

Airport Terminal on Assembly Agenda
27 Nov 2023 15:02

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Possible scenarios for the 2024 renewal of the city’s  [ ... ]

DDF Teams from Sitka, Edgecumbe Score Wins
27 Nov 2023 15:00

By SHANNON HAUGLAND Sentinel Staff Writer Sitka and Mt. Edgecumbe high schools logged a number of  [ ... ]

Weekend City League Games
27 Nov 2023 14:51

By Sentinel Staff In city league basketball games last week, AKO overcame Schmolck Mechanical 59-53 [ ... ]

Other Articles

Daily Sitka Sentinel

Roadless Rule Opponents Change Language


Alaska Beacon

The state of Alaska, a coalition of business groups and a pair of electric-power organizations have opened a new round in the generation-long fight over environmental protections in Southeast Alaska’s Tongass National Forest.

On Sept. 8, the state and two other groups of plaintiffs filed three separate federal lawsuits to challenge a Biden administration rule restricting new roads in parts of the forest, which is home to some of America’s last stands of old-growth trees.

Each lawsuit asks U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason to overturn the new rule and prior versions.  

The Roadless Rule, as it is known, was enacted (and sued over) as early as 2001 by logging proponents, but the latest lawsuits bring a new wrinkle: In more than 100 pages of court documents, the word “logging” appears only once.

Instead, plaintiffs are arguing that the federal government’s rules make clean-energy projects and other economic development unaffordable.

The legal complaints cite prospective geothermal and hydroelectric power plants, as well as hypothetical metal mines whose products could be used for green technologies.

“You’ve got true roadblocks for very desirable projects. These are projects that are going to provide cost savings and environmental benefit,” said Luke Wake, an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing the Inside Passage Electric Cooperative and the Alaska Power Association in one of the lawsuits.

The state of Alaska, which is leading a second lawsuit, has opposed the Tongass Roadless Rule through Democratic, Republican and independent administrations alike.

In a written statement, Gov. Mike Dunleavy said that “Alaskans deserve access to the resources that the Tongass provides — jobs, renewable energy resources, and tourism, not a government plan that treats human beings within a working forest like an invasive species.”

The third lawsuit, which includes the Alaska Chamber of Commerce and Resource Development Council of Alaska among its plaintiffs, is being led by former Gov. and former U.S. Sen. Frank Murkowski, the father of current U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska.

Jim Clark, Frank Murkowski’s former chief of staff and an attorney working on the case, said he remembers when he represented the Alaska Forest Association in a prior lawsuit on the issue.

“This case is old enough to drink in any bar in Alaska,” he said.

In the years since he first worked on the issue, Southeast Alaska’s logging industry has almost entirely vanished. A pulp mill in Ketchikan is now a cruise ship terminal; another in Sitka is a sanctuary for bears.

Overturning the Roadless Rule isn’t about clear-cutting anymore, he said. Instead, it’s about improving access for projects that now need special approval.

“It’s not like we don’t have access under the Biden law, notwithstanding the Roadless Rule, but it is a barrier,” he said.

In legal filings, the Inside Passage Electric Cooperative offered an example: It hopes to build a power line between Kake and Petersburg, allowing those communities to share low-cost power.

The project was expected to cost $17.5 million, but because of the Roadless Rule, it would have to be maintained by helicopter, causing the projected cost to balloon to $65 million.

“As a result of these heightened costs, the Kake-Petersburg Intertie Project remains stalled. But IPEC would resume efforts to further this project if it could obtain road access,” said Jodi Mitchell, IPEC’s CEO, in legal testimony.

Clark said that logging companies aren’t part of these new lawsuits because logging is restricted under a new forest plan, something separate from the Roadless Rule, and the prospects of changing the forest plan are limited.

“There’s no way we’ll be able to change the forest plan to make a difference here,” Clark said.

Kate Glover is an attorney with the environmental law firm Earthjustice, which has participated in prior Roadless Rule lawsuits.

Glover said the attempt to switch to another focus in the Roadless Rule “is certainly noteworthy,” but that the issue “really is about logging,” which was the primary focus of the original rule.

The three lawsuits — which are expected to be combined into one by U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason — will continue a 22-year-old dispute over the extent to which the U.S. Forest Service has the authority under existing law to restrict road building in the forest.

In 2001, the federal government wrote a nationwide rule restricting road building in designated areas. Roads are needed for intensive logging.

The state of Alaska challenged the rule in court, and the federal government agreed to exempt much of Alaska from it.

That changed in 2011, after a federal judge ruled in favor of environmental groups who had filed a lawsuit arguing that the Alaska exemption was unlawful.

The state appealed the verdict and saw it overturned by a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, but a subsequent appeal to the full Circuit Court saw the Alaska exemption again overturned.

The state challenged the legality of the 2001 rule overall in a separate lawsuit filed in Washington, D.C., but lost that case.

After the election of President Donald Trump, the state supported a new roadless rule that allows Tongass development. The Trump administration passed the new rule, but lawsuits stymied its implementation, and the Biden administration’s new rule, enacted in January, overwrites the Trump rule.

Though the state and allied plaintiffs have repeatedly lost in court on the issue, attorneys say the legal groundwork has changed over the past few years.

The U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling in West Virginia v. EPA has the potential to significantly reduce the power of federal agencies to write regulations that aren’t specifically authorized by Congress, and in summer 2024, the Supreme Court is expected to reinterpret a standard known as the “Chevron doctrine” and again restrict the authority of federal agencies.

“All of which makes you think the Supreme Court is more favorable,” Clark said.


Login Form




At a Glance

(updated 9-12-2023)

By Sentinel Staff

The state Department of Health and Social Services has posted the following update on the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases in Alaska as of 8:57 a.m. Tuesday, September 12.

New cases as of Tuesday: 278

Total cases (cumulative) statewide – 301,513

Total (cumulative) deaths – 1,485

Case Rate per 100,000 – 38.14

To visit the Alaska DHSS Corona Response dashboard website click here.

COVID in Sitka

The Sitka community level is now "Low.'' Case statistics are as of Tuesday.

Case Rate/100,000 – 152.50

Cases in last 7 days – 13

Cumulative Sitka cases – 3,575

Deceased (cumulative) – 10

The local case data are from Alaska DHSS.






October 2003

Sitka’s new city engineer, Dan Jones, 51, says his nearly 30 years in the field has given him qualifications for all aspects of his new post. ... He replaces Milt Ludington, who has moved to a different position in the city public works department.



October 1973

One of the most active organizations around town this fall has been the Sitka High Drill Team, the Wolverettes. A spaghetti feed Saturday is the latest project.


Local Events


Daily Sitka Sentinel on Instagram!


Daily Sitka Sentinel on Facebook!